Review by Michael Macomber

Release Date: 04/06/2004
Original Release Date: June 1963 (Atco 33-124)
Arrangements: Torrie Zito & Bobby Scott
Format: CD (1 Disc)
Label: Collectors Choice
Listen to Samples
Get the CD at: Deep Discount - Amazon

This 1963 Atco release is one of the finest LPs Darin ever made. It’s not just a shame, but a downright tragedy that more fans don’t know how amazing an album this is.

Like “Love Swings,” “It’s You or No One” is a concept piece, with bright, warm arrangements by Torrie Zito on Side One, exploring the “It’s You” part of the title, and darker, melancholy arrangements by Bobby Scott on Side Two, falling gently into the “No One” part of the title.

The last song on Side One, “All or Nothing at All” (Johnny Mercer/Victor Schertzinger), does a magnificent job of setting up the lost love theme of Side Two. Darin’s vocal sizzles with passion as he declares “Half a love just never appealed to me. If your heart never could yield to me, then I’d rather have nothin’ at all.” Coming on the heels of the joyous “I’ve Never Been in Love Before” (Frank Loesser), “All or Nothing At All” reveals what could be a hint of desperation, as Darin reaches out for the love he thought was there, and finds the commitment is only half-hearted.

When Side Two commences with “One Little Item” (Libby Holden), we find Darin “in a crowd, so noisy and loud” when his former love walks in. The strings here are astounding, trembling with the flutter in Darin’s chest as he describes his reaction: “When she nears me, how she cheers me, her eyes so warm, so gay. But what can all this matter to me? Those eyes aren’t looking my way.” As the tune comes to a close, Darin lays his pain out for all to see: “She’s everything I told you. I swear by stars above. There’s only one little item… I’m not the guy she loves.” Again, the use of strings is dramatic, magnificent and perfect. The woodwinds are also used to powerful effect.

Recorded in January of 1960, less than a week before Darin would work with Bobby Scott on the “Winners” LP, and a little over a year before he would work with Torrie Zito on “Love Swings,” “It’s You Or No One” was, in some ways, a warm-up for both of those collaborations. Both arrangers had the opportunity to take a set of songs, match them to a mood, and get a feel for the deeply personal way Darin approached a ballad.

Of course, to call this album simply a “warm-up” would be to deny the fact that it stands on its own, as one of the most evocative, emotionally honest, and utterly effective artistic statements on love and loss ever recorded. Darin’s vocal is powerful beyond words, and his unique ability to draw the listener into the very heart of his story is brilliantly represented.

Tracks:

1. It's You Or No One
2. I Hadn't Anyone 'Til You
3. Not Mine
4. I Can't Believe That You're In Love With Me
5. I've Never Been In Love Before
6. All Or Nothing At All
7. Only One Little Item
8. Don't Get Around Much Anymore
9. How About Me
10. I'll Be Around
11. All I Do Is Cry
12. I Guess I'm Good For Nothing But the Blues